Aviation Safety Network
< Home / Aviation Safety Network
Status Accident investigation report completed and information captured
Date Monday 16 February 1998
Time 14:40 LT
Type Silhouette image of generic A320 model; specific model in this crash may look slightly different    
Airbus A320-212
Operator Northwest Airlines
Registration N341NW
MSN 380
Year of manufature 1992
Engines CFMI CFM56-5A3
Crew Fatalities: 0 / Occupants:
Passengers Fatalities: 0 / Occupants:
Total occupants Fatalities: 0 / Occupants: 117
Aircraft damage Minor
Location Memphis, TN   United States of America
Phase En route
Nature Unknown
Departure Airport Detroit, MI (KDTW)
Destination Airport (KMEX)
Narrative While en route from Detroit to Mexico City , the flightcrew received a warning message from the Engine Condition and Monitoring System (ECAS) that the No. 1 fuel filter was clogged. The flight was subsequently diverted to Memphis for a precautionary landing. Post-landing examination of the engine revealed a 4-inch long (circumferential) by 1-inch wide (axial) burn-through in the low pressure turbine case in the plane of the 2nd stage turbine stators at the 11 o'clock location. The examination of the fuel pump filter revealed the presence of a bronze-colored material. The fuel nozzles were reported to have bronze-colored material in the nozzle jets. Records show that the fuel pump had operated 17,208 hours time since new and 6,972 cycles since new. The disassembly of the pump revealed the pump housing had gear pocket milling. The fixed and driven bearings, which are made of bronze, were worn. The fuel pump's filter bypass valve was found to have bronze-colored particles on both sides of the valve. The fuel pump's four bearings were made of bronze and all four bearings exhibited wear and material loss.

Probable Cause: the inadequate (bronze) material used by the fuel pump's manufacturer, which wore and ultimately blocked the fuel filter bypass and partially blocked the fuel nozzles, causing the fuel spray to burn through the low pressure turbine case.

sources

NTSB CHI98IA095

Safety recommendations

Revision History

Date/time Contributor Updates
11-Mar-2024 18:25 ASN Update Bot Added

Contribute

submit additional or updated information